Fantasy football strategy, rankings, and podcasts

This week at drinkfive we take a look at expectations versus reality. Specifically, we will take a look at the top 10 ADP players for each position and where they sit after 12 weeks of the NFL season. We’ll also check out the guys who made it into the top 10 and weren’t drafted there. We like to check in with this every year so that you can get an idea of which way positions are trending over a larger time scale. We also like to know how volatile a position is, which can certainly influence whether or not you decide to spend a high draft pick on someone.

Quarterbacks

Starting at the top of the QB chart, we see right away that Cam Newton is only the 15^th best QB this season. He’s not so bad that you have benched him, which may be worse, considering there’s guys who sit in the top 10 that are generally free agents. Here’s our list of the guys in question:

The QB position, as a whole, is not nearly as consistent as you would assume. Only 4 of the top 10 ADP players are actually in the top 10. They don’t fall off, however, like other positions. We do see that the lowest current rank is 22, Carson Palmer, who had an ADP of 7 – not someone you were betting the house on. Cam Newton or Russell Wilson are the losers of the draft at the QB position this season, and they’re still playing and have just been mild disappointments.

As usual, going with some of the more tried and true names like Rodgers, Brees and Brady has worked out. Tom Brady may have the 22^nd most points overall, but since he missed 4 games, he is averaging the 3^rd most points on average for QB’s, which is perfectly acceptable.

The best value at the position is found in the group of players that were drafted from 12-21. In this group, 6 of them are in the top 10. Overall ADP starts at 100 for Carr, through 152 for Prescott. This means that late in the draft you had plenty of chances to grab a guy, or even take a flier, on someone who would wind up in the top 10. Even with Brady’s average numbers taken into account, it’s still almost never worth drafting a QB early – something we spout all the time. The numbers agree!

Running Backs

The RB position is going to be more risky, just by the nature of the position. Players are more likely to be injured when compared to almost any position, and they’re also more likely to be replaced for ineffective play. Running backs also have a short period of time where they are at their peak (Frank Gore not included), so carrying a performance over year to year can be sketchy. Here’s the way the RBs shake out:

As you can see, unlike the QB position, we have guys who are just gone for the season. This can be both good and bad – good because you replace them and move on with another player (possibly a handcuff), but bad because it’s a wasted early round pick. It is reassuring to see that of the players that did stay healthy, you’re only really burned by taking Todd Gurley. This year, RBs at the top have been very consistent – 5 of the 7 top drafted RBs that are still playing are in the top 10, with Lamar Miller just outside at 13.

It’s a little more difficult to nail down a sweet spot to be drafting RBs. Having a top guy is probably more important than it has been in past years, if only because they’re doing so well this season. With only a 40% failure rate (face it, Todd Gurley is a failure as a #1 pick), taking a risk on a top 10 RB was worth it this season. Only picking up guys in later rounds would not be advisable, since only 2 RBs outside of the top 20 ADP are now top 10 players.

Wide Receivers

Wide Receivers are the players that Dave and I are always going on and on about in preseason podcasts. We frequently recommend taking several at the top of the draft, if only because they tend to be less prone to injury than the other fantasy positions, and because they generally have a better chance to be consistent. Let’s see how we did this year:

While perhaps not the absolute model of consistency, 6 of the 10 WRs that were drafted in the top 10 are still in the top 10 of points. Dez Bryant was injured for many games and is currently 12^th in points per game. Really, Deandre Hopkins is the only player drafted in the top 10 that didn’t deserve to start on your team this season. This is why we stress drafting WR’s early.

If you had drafted 2 or 3 WRs to start your draft, you likely wound up with at least two guys in the top 10, and chances are they are still in the top 10. Again, we see that no players have been lost to season ending injury, though A.J. Green may be. Rounding out our top 10 point scorers are two guys that basically came out of nowhere – Adams and Pryor were so low that they went undrafted in most leagues. Michael Thomas was a semi-popular rookie flier, but he still wasn’t picked until the end of most drafts.

With these results, we will be confidently recommending drafting a bunch of WR’s high again next year. Obviously, they won’t all hit, but the chances of you having your high draft picks making a difference on your team late in the year is far higher if you load up on early round wide receivers.

Tight Ends

This is perhaps the position with the most volatility and is the hardest to predict, solely because there are only about 5 reliable tight ends in the league at any given time. There’s only a couple of guys who you wouldn’t consider replacing for a streaming option every week – Gronk, Walker, Olson, Reed, Graham and Kelce. Let’s see where they fall in our chart:

What we see is that about half of the players drafted in the top 10 actually landed there. The other half, aside from Coby Fleener, are barely worth rostering on a weekly basis (streaming options only). This is middle of the road when compared to other positions, not too great, but not bad either. All of the top 6 players drafted are in the top 11 of scoring. Gronk’s spot looks worse than it is – he got all of his points in only 5 games, so hopefully you had someone else in the other times.

Similar to other positions, TEs are not as injury prone as a RB, so taking the top of the draft class isn’t a huge risk. Overall, this has been a down year for TEs, with the high scorer topping out at only 102. We’re unlikely to have anyone reach the 180+ territory to end the season. I would wager that the average total score for the top 10 finishers this season will be far below the results of the past two years.

What can we learn from this? Well, again, the sweet spot for drafting TEs seems to only lie at the very top of their list. If you are not getting good value on someone during the draft, you will likely need to take a later round flier (again, those are all over) and pay attention to streaming options on a weekly basis.