Fantasy football strategy, rankings, and podcasts

Welcome back to the Rookie Report! We’ve arrived at the final week in the regular season for most fantasy leagues. All your hard work this season may boil down to one game. Maybe you’re still fighting for a playoff spot, or if you’re lucky, fighting for a playoff bye. If you still need a win this week, the NFL schedulers haven’t made it easy on you. There are 6 NFL teams on a bye in week 14, so you may have to get by without a weekly starter like Justin Fields, Aaron Jones, Jonathan Taylor, Terry McLaurin, or Alvin Kamara to get that win. You may be digging deeper than you want to for replacements, and there may be some less heralded rookies who can help…or maybe not.

It's a tough week for the rookies too with those byes. Several rookies who have been viable weekly options are on byes this week – guys like Chris Olave, Christian Watson and Brian Robinson Jr – and a couple others (Treylon Burks & Kenneth Walker III) are in danger of missing the week with injury. Dameon Pierce’s struggles continued to a degree last week, and George Pickens had his worst game of the season, but it’s not all ugly for the rookies. Garrett Wilson, Zonovan Knight, Isiah Pacheco and Cade Otton continued their breakouts, and there could be more good things to come for those players going forward. I’m here once again to take a look at every relevant rookie for week 14, and help you navigate what to do with them in your lineups to put you in the best position to come away with another W.

A couple of housekeeping notes for the players listed below – All players listed under the same header at the same position are listed in the order that I would play them this week, and all references to fantasy points and points allowed rankings are based on half-PPR scoring unless otherwise noted. Any data on route participation, air yards, and other usage rates are per Dwain McFarland’s Utilization Report on Pro Football Focus.

Let’s get into week 14…

Rookies You Already Know You Should Start:

RB Kenneth Walker III, SEA (Wk. 14: vs. Car.): Walker is listed as questionable for this week. He’s not practicing as of Wednesday, but if he’s able to play he should be in your lineup. The Panthers aren’t a defense to be afraid of, allowing the 9^th-most RB points per game and ranking 22^nd in Football Outsiders’ run defense DVOA. It took an injury to prevent Walker from tallying his 8^th straight game with 12+ PPR points, and I expect him to get back on track this weekend if he’s able to suit up. He’s a safe RB2 if healthy.

WR Garrett Wilson, NYJ (Wk. 14: @Buf.): The QB change in New York has been just what the doctor ordered to get Wilson’s season going again. In two games with Mike White under center, Wilson has put up at least a 27% target share, 35% air yardage share, and 24 PPR points in each game. Wilson managed to put up 8 catches for 92 yards on 9 targets in the first meeting with the Bills with Zach Wilson at QB back in week 9, and Mike White should continue to look his way a lot to try and keep pace with Buffalo on Sunday. Buffalo ranks an impressive 7^th in pass defense DVOA, but they’ve allowed the 11^th-most points per game to opposing wide receivers. They’ve allowed 110+ yards to the opposing WR1 in 3 of their last 4 games (to Justin Jefferson, Amari Cooper, and Amon-Ra St. Brown). Wilson is a safe WR2 with a top-5 ceiling even in what looks like a tougher matchup.

Borderline Rookies I’d Lead Toward Starting:

RB Zonovan Knight, NYJ (Wk. 14: @Buf.): Bam Knight has come seemingly out of nowhere to post back-to-back top-24 finishes (one of them a top-12 finish) in his first two games of NFL action. Head coach Robert Saleh has said that Knight will remain in the lead back role this week, even if Michael Carter is able to return from injury. The matchup isn’t an easy one – the Bills rank 3^rd in run defense DVOA and have allowed the 10^th-fewest RB points per game – but the Jets were able to run for over 120 yards in the first meeting with Buffalo, and the Bills’ defense isn’t at full strength. Von Miller is officially out for the season, and DT Jordan Phillips and LB Matt Milano are both not practicing as of Wednesday. Knight is close to a lock for 15+ touches, and he should push for a RB2 finish again with so many top backs off for the week on byes.

RB Isiah Pacheco, KC (Wk. 14: @Den.): The numbers for Pacheco have been strong over the past month. He’s topped 80 scrimmage yards in 4 straight games and scored a TD in each of the last two. There are still some concerns about his underlying usage, but the bottom line is that he’s the clear lead back for one of the most explosive offenses in the league, and that makes him an RB2 option just about every week. Most of the usage concerns for Pacheco stem from a lack of passing game usage and goal-line touches. It seemed that Pacheco had turned a corner in week 12 when he got a dozen red zone carries, but all of that happened with a double-digit lead. Last weekend, with a worse game script, Pacheco’s 8-yard TD in the 3^rd quarter was his only touch in the red zone. Game script should be positive again this week with the Chiefs 9.5-point favorites. Denver has limited RBs to the 9^th-fewest fantasy points per game, but they’re just 17^th in run defense DVOA. They’re far from impenetrable. 3 backs they’ve faced in the last 5 weeks have topped 100 yards on the ground. I wouldn’t call Pacheco a ‘must-start’ if you’ve got solid backs ahead of him, but he’s a strong RB2 option this week.

RB James Cook, BUF (Wk. 14: vs. NYJ): Cook rebounded from a poor fantasy day on Thanksgiving in a big way last week. He was arguably the focal point of the offense against the Patriots in week 13, tallying more rushing attempts than Devin Singletary for the first time all year, and was 3^rd on the team with 6 targets, just 3 fewer than Stefon Diggs. He finished the week as the PPR RB13 without scoring a TD. Cook has been more efficient than Singletary when given opportunities, and the Bills would be wise to continue to give him the ball. Buffalo has been inconsistent in the last few weeks when it comes to their run/pass splits, alternating between being a run-heavy and pass-heavy team in subsequent games. They went pass-heavy against the Vikings and Lions and run-heavy against the Browns and Patriots. Cook was a major beneficiary in the games where they went run-heavy. For what it’s worth, the Jets are more vulnerable on the ground than through the air, though they’re a solid defense overall. New York ranks 5^th in pass defense DVOA, and their outside corners DJ Reed and Sauce Gardner have been phenomenal this year. They rank 11^th in run defense DVOA and have allowed a double-digit fantasy day (half-PPR) to 4 backs in their last 3 games. The Bills’ running backs didn’t have great success against the Jets the first time around, but I think Buffalo has found something in their ground game in recent weeks and will have success this time. Cook’s role is very much in flux this week, but I think the increased usage continues, and he finishes as a top-24 back this week.

WR George Pickens, PIT (Wk. 14: vs. Bal.): Pickens was a huge disappointment last weekend, putting up just 1 catch for 2 yards on 2 targets, and making a scene on the sideline out of frustration with his usage (or lack thereof). The rookie downplayed the significance of the blowup in interviews after the game, but I think he gets the squeaky wheel treatment this week. The Ravens have struggled to limit wide receivers this season, allowing the 8^th-most points per game to the position, and with so many players on byes this week, I think Pickens gets fed enough to post a useful week. Be warned, I don’t think he’s going to put up a monster game here, but 60-70 yards feels like a strong possibility. That ceiling goes up if Diontae Johnson misses this game. Johnson isn’t practicing as of Thursday.

TE Greg Dulcich, DEN (Wk. 14: vs. KC): Last Sunday was a banner day for Dulcich with the top two pass catching options banged up for the Broncos. Jerry Jeudy returned from a multi-week ankle injury and played a limited role (41% route participation rate), and Courtland Sutton suffered a hamstring injury and left the game early, and Dulcich made the most of his expanded opportunity. The rookie tallied 6 catches for 85 yards on 8 targets, good enough for a PPR TE2 finish for the week. It was the 4^th time Dulcich has finished as a top-12 TE in the 7 games he’s played this year, and he’s got a good chance to make it 5 of 8 this week even if Sutton is able to play. If Sutton sits, the ceiling gets even higher for Dulcich. He was used more like a wide receiver last Sunday, spending 54.5% of his snaps lined up in the slot, and he has the 3^rd-highest air yardage total of any tight end since his debut. Dulcich is a top-10 option at tight end this week against a KC defense that ranks 26^th in pass defense DVOA.

Borderline Rookies I’d Lean Toward Sitting:

QB Kenny Pickett, PIT (Wk. 14: vs. Bal.): With only 26 teams in action this week, I can’t just flat out say that you know to sit Kenny Pickett if you’re in a 2-QB league. You might not have any other choice in those formats. Just know that he belongs toward the bottom of the list of those 26 starting QBs in terms of fantasy outlook for this week. The matchup seems favorable on paper, with the Ravens allowing the 12^th-most QB points per game, but Pickett hasn’t shown an ability to cash in on good matchups this season. The rookie has just one top-15 finish all season and hasn’t accounted for more than 1 TD in any of his last 8 starts. The Steelers’ offense as a whole has been better in recent weeks, but that’s been due to a renewed commitment to running the football and not putting too much on Pickett’s shoulders. The rookie has gone 4 straight games without a turnover, but he’s only thrown for 200 yards in one of those games. If you’re looking for 12-15 points from your QB2, Pickett will probably get you that. If you’re looking for more, you should look somewhere else.

RB Rachaad White, TB (Wk. 14: @SF): Leonard Fournette returned to action on Monday night, and White returned to a full-on timeshare role with Lenny. Fournette played 15 more snaps than White against the Saints, but only out-touched him by one (16-to-15). 15 touches isn’t a bad day for a running back, and White did finish the week as the PPR RB10 on the strength of a late TD, but I don’t feel good about his chances of repeating the strong performance in this one. White has largely been inefficient this season, ranking just 41^st in yards per touch out of 52 qualified running backs. He also faces a San Francisco defense this week that has allowed the fewest RB points per game and ranks 2^nd in run defense DVOA. The 49ers haven’t allowed 50+ rushing yards to a back since week 6. They haven’t allowed 40+ receiving yards to a back since week 5, and they’ve allowed only one back to find the end zone in their last 5 games. If White is only going to get half of the workload, his only path to relevance this week will be finding the end zone or piling up a bunch of receptions. I don’t like his chances to score a TD. There could be a little bit more hope on the receiving front – the 49ers have allowed 7 receptions each to Christian McCaffrey and Austin Ekeler this season, and 6 to Alvin Kamara – but even a 5 or 6 catch game might only get White into low-end RB2 range. You might not have better options this week but be warned this is probably a floor game for the rookie.

RB Dameon Pierce, HOU (Wk. 14: @Dal.): Pierce was a bit more effective on the ground last weekend than he’d been in the two games prior, rushing for 73 yards on 18 carries, and ranking in the top-24 PPR finishers for the week. That performance came against arguably the worst run defense in the NFL. Things get much tougher this week. The Cowboys rank 8^th in run defense DVOA and have allowed just the 5^th-fewest RB points per game. They’re also an absurd 17-point favorite. The Texans may abandon the run early in this one, and Pierce has been ceding garbage time work to Dare Ogunbowale in the last couple weeks. There is very real risk here that Pierce puts up another 5-point dud. He’s still almost certain to see double-digit touches, so he’s an RB3 at worst, but be aware of the downside if you’re considering him.

RB Jordan Mason, SF (Wk. 14: vs. TB): It was Mason who emerged as the 49ers new #2 running back with Elijah Mitchell done for the year, which makes him a viable fantasy option in the 49ers run-heavy attack. They’ll likely try to be even more run-heavy with Brock Purdy now playing QB, but McCaffrey dominated the high-value touches last weekend, and likely will going forward. Mason ran a route on just 8% of the team’s passing dropbacks and saw 0% of the short down & distance snaps. If CMC is going to get all the passing work, and all the short yardage/goal line work, it’ll be an uphill fight for Mason to put up fantasy production. He was exceptional last week, putting up 51 yards on 8 carries, but that was good enough to finish as just the RB38 in non-PPR scoring. The Bucs allow the 3^rd-fewest RB points per game, so this is an especially bad week to plug in Mason and hope for success on limited opportunities.

RB Kyren Williams, LAR (Wk 14: vs. LV): The Raiders allow the 6^th-most RB points per game, so any RB who has a meaningful role against them should be in consideration for fantasy lineups, but I don’t have the stomach to rely on Williams this week, especially if you need a win. The Rams’ backfield usage has been an enigma all season. They seemingly have a different lead back each week, often due to injuries, but in some cases with less rhyme or reason. Kyren had his turn as lead back in week 12, handling 14 touches against the Chiefs, but he was down to just 3 touches last Sunday as Cam Akers was re-inserted into the lead role. If you’re confident in a bounce-back in usage for Williams this week, he’s got upside as a RB3 in a good matchup, but I’m not confident in that bounce-back.

WR Treylon Burks, TEN (Wk. 14: vs. Jax.): Burks suffered what looked like a nasty concussion on his TD catch last Sunday. He draws a favorable matchup this week with the Jaguars, who allow the 9^th-most WR points per game and rank 31^st in pass defense DVOA, but it remains very questionable whether he’ll clear the concussion protocol in time to play or not. If he’s able to get cleared, he’ll do so after sitting for most of the week of practice (he’s not practicing as of Thursday), and that could result in him being less involved in the game plan. Burks has big play upside if he’s active and you want to take a swing here, but I’d exercise caution before firing him up.

TE Cade Otton, TB (Wk. 14: @SF): Otton was the PPR TE1 last week, and I would probably sit him this week if you have another reasonable option. Otton got an unexpected boost on Monday night when Cam Brate was a surprise inactive due to an illness. It resulted in Otton playing 82% of the team’s offensive snaps, and even with all that playing time, he didn’t make much of an impact until two frantic scoring drives at the end of the game for a come-from-behind win. Nearly 70% of Otton’s fantasy points were tallied in those last two drives, and the line that made him THE TE1 for the week was just 6-28-1. It was a terrible week for top TE performances. Brate is practicing in full this week, and Otton hasn’t scored even 7 PPR points in any game where Brate has been active. He’s scored 10+ in 4 of the 5 games that Brate has missed. I would assume Brate returns this week, and the 49ers have allowed the 4^th-fewest TE fantasy points per game. Only Tyler Higbee and Travis Kelce have tallied 30+ receiving yards against them from the tight end position. Steer clear of Otton this week.

TE Trey McBride, ARI (Wk. 14: vs. NE): The fact that I’m listing McBride as a ‘borderline’ option at all speaks to just how dire the TE landscape is right now. McBride has been in a full-time role since Zach Ertz got hurt. He’s had a 70% route participation rate or higher in 3 straight games, but he’s totaled just 22 yards on 8 targets in those 3 games. The Patriots have allowed the 10^th-most TE points per game but starting McBride would be just a shot in the dark that he gets on track.

Rookies You Already Know You Should Sit:

RB Jaylen Warren, PIT (Wk. 14: vs. Bal.): The Steelers have shown a renewed commitment to running the ball, but it’s meant a resurgence for Najee Harris, who has posted his 3 highest rushing totals of the season over the last 4 weeks. Warren has been battling a hamstring injury that kept him out for most of weeks 11 & 12, and he came back to just 3 touches on 13 snaps last Sunday. He should at least move back ahead of Benny Snell this week and play a bit more than he did last weekend, but the Ravens have given up just the 6^th-fewest running back points per game. Warren won’t have a big enough role behind Najee to be a good option in that matchup.

WR Skyy Moore, KC (Wk. 14: @Den.): After back-to-back 6-target games for Moore, the bottom fell out last week for the rookie. JuJu Smith-Schuster was back to his usual role after being eased back from his concussion a few weeks ago, but that wasn’t the biggest issue for Moore. Skyy played just about the same snap share as he had in the two prior weeks, but he didn’t earn a single target after earning one on nearly 40% of his routes run over those two prior weeks. Moore’s limited playing team means there will be weeks like this where just doesn’t get involved. The Chiefs have too many weapons for everyone to produce every week. I wouldn’t roll the dice on him getting back on track this week against a Denver defense that allows the fewest WR points per game.

WR Tyquan Thornton, NE (Wk. 14: @Ari.): Thornton has been under a 40% snap share in each of the past 3 weeks and has just 3 catches for 36 yards in those games combined. Four other Patriot wide receivers had a higher route participation rate than Thornton against the Bills. There’s always the threat that Tyquan takes the top off the defense, but I’d rather not start him and have to pray that he does.

WR David Bell, CLE (Wk. 14: @Cin.): I’ve talked up Bell as having upside when Deshaun Watson returns from his suspension, but Watson’s debut put that notion to bed quickly. Bell had been seeing his role grow in the weeks leading up Deshaun’s return, but inexplicably the Browns chose to deploy Demetric Felton as their primary slot receiver last Sunday. Bell played just 3 snaps while Felton played 38. Felton wasn’t targeted even once, but he was on the field a ton. It could just be a product of facing a bad Texans team, or just a one game blip, but either way you can’t plug Bell into lineups anywhere for this week.

TE Isaiah Likely, BAL (Wk. 14: @Pit.): The tight end pool is a dumpster fire outside of the top few options, but don’t be fooled into thinking Likely is in play after his 4-catch game last week. 3-4 weekly targets is pretty the most you can reasonably hope for while Mark Andrews is healthy. That’s not enough to take a chance on Likely against a middling Steelers’ defense.

TEs Jake Ferguson & Peyton Hendershot, DAL (Wk. 14: vs. Hou.): There may be some DFS upside here with the Cowboys an absurd 17-point favorite against the Texans. All the Cowboys’ backups could get some run in this game, and that includes the pair of backup tight ends. Both players have limited ceilings, so I’d limit exposure to Showdown contests. Hendershot is the much cheaper option ($400 on DraftKings compared to $1,800 for Ferguson), but Ferguson is the one who is on the field more and has seen more opportunities in recent weeks. Ferguson has seen 7 targets come his way in the last 3 games, while Hendershot has just 1 catch and one rushing attempt in the last 4. Both guys are just TD dart throws here anyway, but if this really does turn into the rout that it’s supposed to, it could be Hendershot who benefits since Ferguson may be viewed as more important to the offense (he’s played more than 45% of the offensive snaps in 4 of the last 5 games).

Rookies on Bye: RB Tyler Allgeier, ATL, RB Brian Robinson Jr., WAS, RB Trestan Ebner, CHI, WR Drake London, ATL, WRs Chris Olave & Rashid Shaheed, NO, WRs Christian Watson & Romeo Doubs, GB, WR Jahan Dotson, WAS, WR Alec Pierce, IND, TE Jelani Woods, IND, TE Cole Turner, WAS

Rookies Who May as Well Be on a Bye: RB Isaiah Spiller, LAC, RB Keaontay Ingram, ARI, RB Tyrion Davis-Price, SF, RB Raheem Blackshear, CAR, RB Zamir White, LV, WR Jalen Tolbert, DAL, WR Khalil Shakir, BUF

Deep League Sleepers, Stashes, and Cheap DFS Options:

QB Brock Purdy, SF (Wk. 14: vs. TB): The 49ers season appeared to take a catastrophic turn last week when Jimmy Garoppolo was carted off after being tackled awkwardly by a Miami defender. Testing this week has confirmed that Garoppolo is done for at least the regular season, but if Purdy’s play in relief of Jimmy G last week is any indication, the 49ers’ championship hopes might not be completely dead yet. The rookie commanded the huddle and played surprisingly well in his debut. The 49ers were already a run-first offense, and they’ll certainly remain that way with Purdy under center, but when he needed to throw, Purdy was decisive and put the ball on-target. I’m sure there will be bumps along the way as defenses throw different wrinkles at him, and the Bucs are a tougher matchup this week (8^th in pass defense DVOA), but Purdy looks up to the task of guiding the 49ers down the stretch. With the weapons at his disposal, and Kyle Shanahan calling the plays, I’d view Purdy as a weekly mid-range QB2 who could post some spike weeks when things break his way. He shouldn’t be on the waiver wire in 2-QB leagues.

QB Desmond Ridder, ATL (Wk. 14: Bye): Ridder is on a bye this week, but the time to pick him up in redraft superflex leagues is now. He’s likely already rostered in dynasty leagues, but Arthur Smith has hinted that a QB change may be coming after the bye week with the Falcons essentially out of playoff contention. The Atlanta offense will cap his passing upside, but Ridder has a bit of Konami code rushing upside to tap into. If you were starting Jimmy Garoppolo, Marcus Mariota, or Lamar Jackson in a superflex league, Ridder could be a valuable add for the stretch run. Atlanta’s opponents in week 16 & 17 (Baltimore and Arizona) are both in the bottom 12 defenses at limiting QB fantasy points. Arizona is in the bottom 5.

UPDATE: The Falcons have officially named Ridder as their starting QB for week 15

WR Jameson Williams, DET (Wk. 14: vs. Min.): Firing up Williams this week in season-long leagues is probably off the table for you after seeing the rookie play just 8 snaps and earn 1 target in his debut last week. The team offensive coordinator Ben Johnson was quoted as saying he hopes Williams will have a bigger role moving forward but noted that “I don’t know what that means necessarily for the rep count.” With that kind of tepid endorsement, it’s hard to have much confidence in a breakout game this week for Williams, but the opportunity could be there. The Vikings rank 24^th in pass defense DVOA and have allowed the 3^rd-most WR points per game. Jameson is also a big play waiting to happen – he can burn defenses on the deep ball, or with yards after the catch – and the Vikings have struggled to defend both this year. Minnesota has allowed the 5^th-most air yards on completions this year, and the 2^nd-most yards after catch. It’s mostly just an upside swing if you plug Williams into your DFS lineups this week, but there’s room for a big ceiling if he gets the opportunities.

TE Chig Okonkwo, TEN (Wk. 14: vs. Jax.): Okonkwo has now posted a 30+ yard catch in 4 of his last 5 games, and 5 targets in each of the last two, and he could see an expanded receiving role this week if fellow rookie Treylon Burks isn’t able to clear the concussion protocol prior to the game. Okonkwo was in a route on 78% of the team passing dropbacks after Burks left the game and earned a 25% target share. The Jaguars have given up 100+ yards to opposing tight ends in two of their last 3 games, and 80+ in 3 of their last 5. There’s top-5 upside for Okonkwo if Burks is out. He’s more of fringe TE1 streaming option if Burks can suit up.

TE Daniel Bellinger, NYG (Wk. 14: vs. Phi.): Bellinger returned from IR last week and immediately stepped back into a full-time role, playing 97% of the offensive snaps and posting an 81% route participation rate. He didn’t put up much production (5-24 on 5 targets), but he was facing off with a Washington defense that allows the 2^nd-fewest TE points per game. This week he faces an Eagles’ defense than allowed 4-68 to Chig Okonkwo last week in their first game without CJ Gardner-Johnson at safety. The Eagles are still allowing just the 8^th-fewest TE points per game for the year, but they’ve been showing cracks defensively in the middle of the field. Bellinger isn’t more than a fringe streaming option this week for 12-team leagues or deeper, but there’s solid DFS potential here as well with just a $3,300 price tag on DraftKings. 

That’s all I’ve got for this week. Hopefully it helps you pick up another big win this weekend. Feel free to hit me up on Twitter (@Shawn_Foss) if you have any questions or want to yell at me about anything written above, and always make sure to apply what’s written in the context of your own league rules and roster. Keep a close eye on the injury report throughout the week and do a final pre-game check to make sure you don’t start any inactive players. As always: Good luck, trust your gut and have fun. It’s just a game.