Fantasy football strategy, rankings, and podcasts

You saw it out there - it was a massacre. Weeks like this happen from time to time during an NFL season, but the sheer number of injuries to prominent fantasy players in one week was enough to make team manager cry. And I'm betting quite a few people out there that had guys like Saquon Barkley and Christian McCaffrey drowned their fantasy football sorrows with a few glasses of whiskey. Regardless, the show must go on and I'm here to provide a guide to those players that you may want to get on your active roster in a hurry. Here's hoping that week 3 doesn't put even more people on the injured reserve!

Guys that jump out to me this week to overperform expectations: Matt Ryan, Michael Gallup, A.J. Green, Chris Herndon, Dalton Schultz, and the Arizona Cardinals (DST). 

Pay attention to these rankings throughout the season, as they will continue to evolve based on the latest injury updates, news, and player analysis. Have any specific lineup questions? Feel free to tweet us @drinkfive with any of your questions or comments!

Mike Davis (CAR) – So, it’s the end of the world as McCaffrey owners know it, and they won’t be fine for 4-6 weeks until he returns. In the meantime, Mike Davis was a hot commodity on the waiver wire. Davis could hardly get anything going last year, and his 8 receptions in garbage time last week surpassed his catch total for all of 2019. Aside from garbage time, which the Panthers are likely to find themselves in most weeks, I don’t expect Davis to be able to do very much at all. This week, the Panthers have to travel across the country to LA and play the Chargers, a team that seems to play up and down to their competition. Down is the keyword this week, I expect this game to mostly be a lot of bleh with some meh thrown in. I don’t expect much out of Davis this week, or at all while McCaffrey is out to be honest. He is not a suitable replacement in your lineup for CMC and you need to rely on the bench depth that you drafted instead of a desperation waiver wire pickup.

David Johnson (HOU) – Johnson briefly, very briefly, reminded us on opening night of the player he used to be. Last week was a different story. Given the same opportunities (11 carries, 4 targets each game), he managed a mere 50 yards from scrimmage against the Ravens. This week gets no easier when the Texans travel the Pittsburgh. The Steelers defense completely shut down Saquon Barkley in week 1 and are giving up the 4^th fewest fantasy points to opposing RBs. With the Texans struggling this year after inexplicably trading away their best player not named DeShaun Watson, it’s going to take some time and more than an RB past his prime to fix this team. David Johnson is a bad fantasy start this week.

Jordan Reed (SF) – Reed found the end zone twice on Sunday and reminded us all of better times, like way back in 2015 when he could score TDs and we didn’t have to wear masks everywhere. If George Kittle sits, then Reed is going to be his replacement. While Kittle may be healthier than last week, he might still sit considering all the chirping that the 49ers have done regarding the turf at Metlife Stadium, where they played last week and will play again this week. This leaves a perfect storm of Jordan Reed completely returning to the player that we know him to be – a guy who gets injured all the time. Reed seems to be perfectly set up to get bitten by the turf monster if he does get the start this week, and I freely admit that I am not using a lot of numbers to make this call. Just don’t play Jordan Reed because he’s going to let you down as he has in many years past.

Justin Herbert (LAC) – Herbert had an impressive game last week when he was thrust into the starting role just before kickoff. Without any time to think about it, he scrambled well and threw the ball with a rocket arm, if not perfect accuracy. He did seem to make a couple of rookie mistakes, like the INT he threw late in the game to let the Chiefs back in it. This week he faces the Panthers and surprisingly, they have given up the 2^nd fewest points to opposing QBs. Perhaps this is due to the fact that they’re letting everybody and their mother run rampant over them. I expect a whole week to think about the start to make Herbert look more like a typical rookie, and for the Chargers to really lean on the run game. So, Herbert was only relevant in 2 QB leagues. Definitely roster him, but I wouldn’t dive in and start him until he puts a couple of good games together.

Matt Ryan (ATL) – Once or twice a year, Matty Ice is going to deliver you a proper dud. The Bears are giving up the 4^th fewest points to opposing QBs, so even though Ryan has had a good streak to start the season, I think he’s going to run into a wall this week in Chicago. The Bears limited Matt Stafford to 1 TD in Week 1, and kept Daniel Jones under 10 fantasy points last week, so they’ve had a strong showing every week so far. The only thing that Ryan might have going for him is that he will probably throw the crap out of the ball to try and get out of the 0-2 hole the Falcons find themselves in. This is just going to lead to turnovers and more misery as the Falcons find themselves as the best 0-3 team, and the Bears will find themselves as the worst 3-0 team.

Welcome to Statistically (in)Significant, the place to find great stats that probably only matter at the water cooler (or bar). Each week I'll dig through the stats of the week gone by and deliver you some choice conversation starters. All fantasy stats are half PPR scoring unless otherwise noted.

42 Pass Completions

If I told you that the franchise record for passing completions for the Colts was 42, you would immediately think of Peyton Manning. Nope, he only has 40. Maybe you would remember Andrew Luck – also topped out at 40, also against Houston, just like Peyton. It turns out, that record now belongs to Matt Ryan, who completed 42 of his 58 pass attempts on Sunday. I guess that’s really called for when Jonathan Taylor has to sit for his second straight game. Ryan threw 13 more passes than the next closest QB (Jacoby Brissett with 45), and had 13 more completions than the next highest total (Garoppolo with 29). Ryan may not be scoring a ton of points in Indy this year, but he’s led the team to a winning record and he has thrown the ball at least 37 times in all but one game this season. There may not be a lot of fantasy production from Ryan, though he is definitely a starting superflex QB every week, there’s value to be found at the WR position. 4 of their WRs are averaging at least 3 catches per game, and 8 players have at least double-digit receptions (Jonathan Taylor not among them).

28.6 Fantasy Points

Ja’Marr Chase led all WRs in fantasy points this week, putting up 7 catches for 132 yards and scoring 2 touchdowns. His 28.6-point total was the second-highest of the week, behind his QB, Joe Burrow. Both players seemed to relish in their return to Louisiana, where they won a national championship with LSU. It’s the 4^th time in 23 regular season games that the pair have connected on multiple touchdown passes in one game. Chase has 7 games with 100+ receiving yards in his career, and now 6 games with over 20 fantasy points. He’s the WR5 on this season after this performance, despite half his games being under 9 fantasy points. His forever-teammate, Joe Burrow, is also 5^th at his position in fantasy points. He’s been a bit more consistent, accumulating a respectable total with only two top-5 finishes this season.

19 Total Points

Thursday night football has really been stinking it up lately. It’s best to go ahead and make dinner reservations on Thursdays if the last two games are any indicator. Week 6’s matchup between the Bears and the Commanders was just 3-0 at halftime. Chicago, despite rushing for a ridiculous 238 yards, generated only 7 points. This just goes to show that imbalance I have spoken of over the last few weeks is still a big problem, and not resulting in any good outcomes for the Bears. The previous Thursday resulted in only 2 more points, a 12-9 game that excruciatingly went into overtime – extra football that nobody asked for. Tonight, we’re being given our 4^th primetime look at the Broncos in 6 weeks. Someone at the scheduling office is clearly a fan of bad football. The Saints @ Cardinals this coming Thursday does nothing to dispel that notion. The only advice I can give is to bet on bad football and not start anyone on Thursdays if you can help it.

116 Rushing Yards

Breece Hall is really getting going now in his rookie season. This week, he posted his first game with 100+ rushing yards. He’s now scored a rushing TD in 3 straight weeks – all of them victories for the Jets. He’s averaging 5.6 yards per carry over the last 2 games, and though he’s had only 2 targets per game in the last 3 games, he’s still 3^rd in the league in receiving yards among running backs. Hall is the RB6 on the season and is putting up very consistent fantasy points. He has at least 12 points in every game other than week 1. He has increased his carries every single week, and is averaging just over 5 yards per carry on the season. Hall is really having the season you hoped for if you drafted him first overall in dynasty leagues, and the Jets are surprisingly good, though apparently, it’s not very surprising to them.

616 Rushing Yards

The Jets, however, aren’t even the best team from NYC. The Giants are 5-1, showing that their win last week was not a fluke with this week’s comeback against the Ravens. The Giants now have more wins this season than they did all last year when they went 4-13. Led by Saquon Barkley, the RB2 in fantasy, he has the 2^nd most rushing yards in the league, the 7^th most receiving yards among RBs, and leads the league in rushing attempts. Barkley looks like the player he was in his first two seasons. He has at least 17 points in all but 1 game this year. His next 4 matchups are very favorable, including one against the Texans, who are giving up the most fantasy points to opposing WRs. All 4 of those opponents are giving up top 10 points to opposing RBs. Barkley could definitely be a player to target if you need that one more piece on your squad to put you over the top.